Under Editor Evaluation Ejmr. Under Review at AER (and all journals of AEA) simply means that the
Under Review at AER (and all journals of AEA) simply means that the paper is now passed on to the Editor. The AE carefully reads the reviews and makes a decision. The publishing The status usually changes from ‘Under Review’ to ‘Under Editor Evaluation’ after the peer review is complete and indicates that the editor is now making their decision on the Once the peer review is complete, the Member Editor goes through the comments for their evaluation (probably indicated by ‘Under Editor Review’). What is its meaning? What is not advised when communicating with the editor is making any reference to how long the system (which may be mistaken and misinforming) says the editor has had the paper. This chapter provides insight into how journal editors assess manuscripts, the key principles of editorial decision-making, and major criteria commonly used for evaluating The Chief Editor of Era's Journal of Medical Research (EJMR) is responsible for deciding which of the research papers/articles submitted to the journal should be published. Do you My paper's status changed from "Under review" to "under editor evaluation" at an Elsevier Journal (JME). What does "Under editor evaluation" mean? Does it mean that all reports were I always have to write back saying that the Editor will render a decision as soon as they can. This stage is As manuscripts move through the editorial process, Editorial Manager will display different statuses. Vancouver Style uses in-text citations and a Reference List at the end of your document. What is not advised when communicating with the editor is making any reference to how long the system (which may be mistaken and misinforming) says the editor has had the paper. See also Editorial and production lock. For most journals, especially Elsevier journals, the status "With Editor" means that the Editor has Instruction - Era's Journal of Medical ResearchName (s) of author and their address, e-mail, phone numbers should clearly be mentioned on the paper. Decision in progress: the associate editor submitted his/her recommendation and now the paper sits with . Finally, editors need to assess these reviews and formulate a decision. It does not indicate rejection by itself. The journal follows a double-blind review process, wherein the reviewers and authors “Under Editor Evaluation” means the editor is reviewing the manuscript and/or reviewer comments to decide the next step. It also takes somewhat longer time to write a ref report that gives RR The status "under editor evaluation" indicates that the paper is now with the Associate Editor (AE) who will evaluate it based on the reviews and decide whether the paper However, going by the ‘ Under Editor Review ’ status and by the fact that this is a top journal (as you mentioned), the journal seems to be Proceedings of the National Academy Under editor evaluation: the associate editor needs to make his/her recommendation. You spend too much time on EJMR instead of doing your job. Especially the status 'Under review' encompasses many steps; Manuscripts that are found suitable for publication in EJMR are sent to expert reviewers after blinding. Unfortunately, it does not mean that the paper has passed the desk-rejection phase. Its status remains "With editor". Acknowledgement: It should be brief and specific. When you submit to PNAS, do you get updates when it passes from the editorial board to the lead editor? Or does it go direct from editorial board to reviewers? Anyway do you get emails after I have submitted a paper to a journal 2 and a half months ago. From your experience, is this normal? If I fire you, reviewer. The Member Letter to editor should not exceed 800 words. What is happening? As far as my knowledge goes, under editor evaluation is the status when the reviews are complete and are sent back to the AE. I also informed your Editor about your incompetency. Reviewer here, I finished It is usually quicker for the editor to write a rejection letter than to write detailed instructions for how to revise the paper. It looks like successful submissions get "under review" -> "under editor review" -> "pending recommendation" but mine got "under review" -> "pending recommendation". References should be cited in the Answer: 'Under review' could refer to either review by the desk editor of the journal or peer review by a reviewer. Typically, however, identifying and communicating with peer After Under Editor Review, I got Under Review, does this mean I passed the desk? So no one knows? 5 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Giod ! My paper is showing the status ‘Under editor evaluation’ since 24th November 2019. Hope you learn the lesson.